Interesting link kanelli - it shows that a lady photographer was arrested, beaten, tortured and raped and finally killed whilst in custody. It also shows that there were trials for the crime.
You bring up this horrific case as evidence that Iran may not be as 'civilised' as many countries in the West.
I think you are saying that this event is somehow a reflection of status of free-speech, women's rights, prisoner abuse in Iran and that this is worse than many western countries.
You may be right. This may be an example that shows how ruthless and oppressive the Iranian regime is. On the other hand, you may be wrong and this is a crime that is not typical of the regime.
As we are trying to compare Iran with the West, we need to see whether there are any comparable controversial deaths in custody or incidents of torture and murder by governments.
Well, on the deaths in custody - the US and UK (who I know about) have a long list of controversial and suspcious deaths. Continental Europe also has it's own cause celebres in each country. (anyone remember Rodney King?)
On the torture front - renditions and allegations of sending suspects to be tortured in Eastern Europe are a current hot topic of human rights organisations.. a stance which is just as bad as actually torturing people yourself - renditions are basically saying 'we know this is wrong, but we are going to export the problem to 'friends' who will torture on our own behalf'. Another example is Guantanamo Bay - this is torture according to most people.
Therefore, could not a rational person make a good arguement for Iran being more civilised than the USA?
Cheers,
Shafique