I skimmed, but not not read the whole thread "question to MCL", but I think this is somewhat related. I know there are many Dubai lovers on the forum and in the country in general, but the following are my observations. Expats are ANYONE that is a resident here, but not a National. After that, the expats are generally broken down into various categories...labour, domestic, service, business,executives, etc.
Let's remember that not all UAE Nationals are monied-up Sheikhs either. There are loads of poor and working class Emiratis. My rub on the whole thing is that there is a sense of "entitlement" here. Mostly attributed to the middle and upper class Nationals, but this sense of entitlement is infectious and I find the longer (some) people have been here, the stronger their sense of entitlement is. I'll admit it, when I got here I thought, "I'm not cleaning, driving, gardening, not doing ANYTHING...I live in Dubai and that is how it is". That did not last long as I like washing my car, every maid or houseboy I hired sucked, I am a defensive driver who does not want my car trashed in my absence, and I am a DIY kinda guy. After about 3 months, I was all of the above...except gardener....he was good and I killed the grass.
I can't speak for the Nationals, but I have seen Indian expats with a 1br flat that have a maid because "that's what you do here". They live cheque to cheque, yet need a maid. I know a bunch of 30-somethings that live together like college kids, yet have a maid because "it's cheap here". They trash the house and the maid cleans up and does their laundry. The watchman at my compound looks in horror and flies down the driveway should he "catch" me bringing the garbage out myself. Is this sense of entitlement as bad as I see? Sure, hire domestic help if you can afford it and afford them a good lifestyle. I know lots of people that treat their help, their friends and family well. We all came here for a more rewarding life regardless of origin or motivation.
I am pretty certain that if all the maids, drivers, houseboys, laborers, taxi/bus drivers and petrol station attendants took a week off at the same time, this place would implode. Does living here entitle you to treat domestic staff as slaves? Does living here entitle you to speak down to those you feel have lesser qualifications than you? Does living here simply give you your "douchebag" wings? Keep in mind, every single one of us will be leaving at some time.
A few chapters from my week:
1) A client of mine (15 year resident) did not know what a multimeter was when I asked to borrow one. This is an ex-UK military guy that was allegedly a radio operator and ran the communications systems. WTF? This same client has his maid unload groceries from the car, has the maid drag his Hobie-Cat up the beach when he is finished with his sailing adventure, and has no issues calling me at midnight when Al Jazeera buggers up the football broadcast to see if I can come over and fix it. How soon they forget.
2) A British friend of mine who is having relationship issues is crashing at mine for a short time till he finds a new place. He was shocked to find out we have no domestic help. I am the maid and clean the villa as the wife works full time as well as school so I make the effort. (Plus, sadly I am better and faster) He was genuinely concerned about pulling his weight as he has not done laundry or done anything domestic in 10 years. His words to me "I just left things anywhere because they would be gone tomorrow". I have to "show him how to do laundry" tomorrow. After dinner tonight, he was very keen to clear up, but as he stood there in the kitchen, it was obvious he had no clue what to do. He subsequently said he would hire a maid for the villa for the duration of his stay!
3) At my home away from home Sunday (Dubai Courts). I was case #5 so knew I would be fast. The opposition's lawyer could not read English nor the Arabic translation I had. He needed his Sudanese (or other) consultant to explain to him what it meant. SHOCK. After getting his notes translated, the translator asked me if the lawyer was 5 years old, as the statement was replete with errors, but he translated verbatim. He then gave me an "interpretation" of what he thought the lawyer was saying. As you may know, only the Plantiff, Defendant or an EMARATI lawyer may approach the judge. It is the consultants that know the laws and do the prep and interpretation. Becoming a lawyer here is simple, provided you are a National.
4) After the above, I went to have a coffee in the Gloria Jeans. It was very busy as per usual. I got in line and waited and noticed all tables were full except for 3 dirty ones. After repeated attempts from Emarati lawyers to cut the line (I don't put up with it and tune them in) I finally got my snack. One fat old dude had been barking the whole time for the staff to clean the tables. The staff were clearly busy as heck and were preparing orders and could not do it. As my order was done, I walked to a table and cleared it myself, fatso promptly sat down. I told him that the table was for me. He mentioned he was a lawyer, I said that was wonderful, I am a litigant, go clear your own table. And I parked my butt. Fatso whined the whole time about clearing the table. Rather than do it himself, he took his coffee and sat in the attached bank's chairs. He whined so much and so long, I finished my muffin and half a coffee. When he saw I was leaving he sprung from his seat to take my table. I just left my tray there and moved another from an adjacent table for good measure.