I can write a letter and state anything I want in it, would that make what I say fact? If you were about to carry out a terrorist attack and gave your reasons for carrying out the attack, then yes, the reasons you give in the letter would make it a fact. The fact would be 'the reasons the terrorist...
For Jews and Muslims, male circumcision is seen as logical and a commandment from God. In Islam, circumcision is not mentioned in the Quran, but it was a teaching/instruction of the Prophet. I do understand the anti-circumcision argument that an infant has no choice in the matter, and indeed have ta...
Bora why talk in generalities when the specific question was the motivation for the WTC 93 bombing. The terrorist who carried out the bombing said it was for political motives - US foreign policy in Mid East. He did not mention Islam/Jihad etc. Just believing he must have done for Islamic reasons do...
Err, I think you mean 'not believing in hype and trusting the evidence' don't you? It takes a perverse logic to criticise someone for quoting a terrorist stating the reason for an attack, when discussing the reason for the attack. But that's just me - I don't invent reasons when the terrorists don't...
Well, then we have to agree to disagree. I don't think Jews and Muslims cite medical reasons as the primary reason for male circumcision - the primary reason is religious. As I stated, the fact that there is a medical benefit (and complications are few and far between) - I think it is a custom that ...
You are apparently wishing the reason the terrorist gave was 'It was Islam that made me do it' - but instead, he said it was only US foreign policy. I'm struggling to see why a supposed Jihadist would NOT mention religion if that was part of the motivation. The only conclusion is that your logic tha...
I read your posts and was intrigued that you were trying to convince me that the WTC 93 attack was religiously motivated, when the reasons given by the terrorists only mentioned US foreign policy. I understood the links and logic you were trying to support this theory - but I still can't ignore the ...
I think it makes sense in an evolutionary sense - we have vestigial appendages, eg the appendix and what remains of a tail - and indeed wisdom teeth. I think at some time in the evolutionary past a foreskin may have proferred some benefit that outweighed the downsides of having one. At the stage of ...
Well, I'd like to just state that I DO indeed believe there are indeed jihadists and other religiously motivated terrorists out there (Goldstein was one, Brievik another - and there are many Muslim groups who target other sects and religions because of their religious views). However, the point in t...
Interesting perspective! Still, from what I have read about the foreskin. there are very few disadvantages to having one, clothing or not. I agree - I just gave you that perspective in light of the 'cruel and pointless' remark. The more I think of it, Wisdom Teeth are a good example of vestigial or...
Ok, let's look at the evidence. As stated in the OP: While religion contributes in many cases to increased feelings of loyalty toward a kindred community that may be oceans away from an individual’s country of citizenship, the primary cause of these horrible phenomena is foreign occupation. Are the ...
I don't recall reading what terrorist group Baruch Goldstein was affiliated with?? Can you provide the name of that group? He was a member of the Jewish Defence League in the USA - it is a Kahanist terrorist organisation that carried out bombings and assassinations in the USA in the 70's. He then e...
What are the benefits of female circumcision or genital sewing? Do they outweigh the harm/dangers? Does any scripture say God asks this of the believers in that scripture? If not, why would it be logical to endorse that act? I presume you don't object to Jews and Muslim saying that for them it is lo...
So, are you unclean after touching a chair? Or is the Bible wrong? Islam's teachings are very logical - and yes, women who are menstruating are allowed to pray to God and recite verses of the Quran. They do not take part in the formal 5 daily prayers and some women choose to not touch the Quran phys...
Thanks - can we see some numbers for the nationalities of the suicide bombers in Iraq and what the sources for this info are. The above snippet is quite general - 'widespread agreement' seems to imply that there some real evidence underlying the assertion. Please quantify the 'large number of Saudis...
Ok folks. There's been a lot of heat generated and quite a bit of repetition ;) Let me sum up what the evidence says to me and what my view is. Others can hold different views and can give more credence to other pieces of information. 1. Are there other trans-national terrorist groups like Al Qaeda?...
So eh, in summary, you are calling Jews and Muslims 'dumb' for believing that God was wise and had a good reason to require males to be circumcised. I've detailed why it is logical for us - primarily it is because God asked us to do it, and secondly because the advantages are there, and the disadvan...
eh - I've given you the logic, I've given you the link to Islamic resources. Women can pray - just not the 5 congregational prayers. Women can recite the Quran - all are agreed on this. Some women/scholars say women shouldn't touch the Quran physically, but not all Scholars/Women agree with this int...
Hey hervey baby - welcome back! I was wondering whether you'd been recruited by the JDL - given their recruiting in France these days. http://www.dubaiforums.com/dubai-politics-talk/jewish-terrorists-recruiting-france-t47383.html But, to answer your question - no, I'm not putting words into terroris...
eh - really :roll: - did you not read the posts above and have you already forgotten that women do go to the mosque for Friday sermon when menstruating? There IS unanimous agreement that women can recite the Quran - read the article again. Touching the Quran is a separate issue. Just because you app...
This thread is not about Baptism or crucifixion. I've detailed the secondary reason for Muslims and Jews to routinely circumcise males - that there are some advantages and the disadvantages are fewer. Your problem is that this view is shared by many doctors who DO recommend routine circumcision. I a...