Dubai Forums Dubai Discussions Dubai Politics Talk

So, if Iran trains groups within a country and supplies them with arms, then this is bad. But when the US and Israel do the same, this is good.

It does appear that Chomsky has a point that the loons etc have a weird way of looking at the world.

Kurds who are killed by Turkey are terrorists, but Kurds trained by Israel are good guys. Now, given that Turkey has killed Kurds in Iraq, we'd expect the logic to break down here in a logic loop. However, Loon logic seems to be immune from these niceties which we call 'consistency'.



Cheers,
Shafique

Yes, logic loop - such as condemning massacres of civilians and the forced expulsion of tribes but condoning Muhammad's actions, in which his armies carried out both.

I'm also a bit confused on how you think that this is an inconsistency in my logic.

And where exactly did Iran come into play? Are they training members of the PKK?

LoL.

Your attempts at 'outwitting' others are pretty lame.

Kurds who are killed by Turkey are terrorists, but Kurds trained by Israel are good guys

Yes, that made sense.

Kurdish members of the peshmerga (a branch of the Kurdish security forces) are trained by Israelis.

I hope you don't think the peshmerga=PKK

Your rambling again eh.

Is it a coincidence that everytime you can't jump to Israel's defence (eg pro-apartheid demonstrations, siege being unceremoniously loosened etc) you ramble on thus? There's a clear pattern emerging.

Cheers,
Shafique

Sorry, couldn't see the connection or loop in logic regarding your comment that I quoted.

Perhaps you can explain to me how it's a loop in logic to try and see Turkey's reasons for defending her borders against armed insurgents vs Israel training members of the Iraqi security forces?