jayzed wrote:My contract (with a company in the DIFC) has a pretty standard non-compete clause that prevents me working for a competitor for six months. I'm not planning to leave immediately but may want to switch jobs at some point in the next year or so. Because I work in a pretty specialised area, I would almost certainly move to a direct competitor.
Does anyone have any experience or insight into whether non-compete agreements are enforced in practice in the UAE, and how easy/difficult it is for a company to enforce non-compete restrictions through the courts? I assume that the applicable law/court in this case would be the DIFC employment law and the DIFC courts.
Unless the 'no competition" clause was agreed to under duress, is ureasonably long or unrelated to your line of work, it will be "enforceable".
Finding out whether it is "enforceable" in any venue: court, arbitration, etc. is only part of the issue.
Here are just two scenarios:
1.You leave the company and go work for a competitor. In the process you take clients, trade secrets and/or business away from your present employer. Any Employer concerned about its business will sue you and seek and injuction from the court preventing you from working for the new company (in addition to immigration issues if applicable). This will involve costs and agrevation for you and your new employer. The most likely scenario is that 6 months will pass before the matter is resolved during which there would be great expense. After the 6 months the case would be "moot" as you would be free to be employed by the competitor.
It the non-competion term is longer (but reasonable) then more expense and aggrevation.
2. You leave your company and work for a competitor. You take no client or business away from your employer. The employer would care less about where you go as it does not impact its business.
In either case above, whether or not the clause is "enforceable" is not an issue that is decided by a court. It is simply a "business" decision.
Most, if not all, employment contracts in UAE seem to have this non-competition clause even if non-applicable. Someone saw such clause somewhere and decided it was a good idea to copy it - copy cats abound.
Surely there are cases, where the issue of enforceability of the non-competition are worth litigating. These usually involve huge business, trade secrets, etc. and almost always involve senior level individuals joining the direct competitors.
In any event, the UAE is a Civil Code Jurisdiction so that the concept of "precedent" need not be followed so that each case is ajudicated case-by-case!
The bottom line is that an Employer should not be a place for training its competitors. The non-competion clause is and should be enforced, in the right case, in order to maintain some semblance of "business order" - plus the lawyers need feeding from time to time. The insertion of such clause is a matter of "negotiations"
before you sign the employment contract (sometimes that "negotiation" opportunity is not present).
It's like the speeding: is the law enforced? Only if you get caught!