Aug 02, 2005
ok guys ,,, well,, first i would agree with Liban tooo much ,, not only because he and i are muslims , but also ,, coz its important ,, the nature of one kid - for sure- is not the same of another kid . so ,, with a kid it might work just to talk to him/her ,,, with another ,, the "LOOK" might be enough - as pumpkin said - ,,, with another one ,, you may have to hit a little ,, for me ,,,, for example , my mother used to lock me in the room ,, and i think its a common thing ,, but this was enough with me ,, with my brother it wasnt ,,, my mother had to hit him .
now for allowing hitting in Islam , its allowed yes,,,but its limited you cant even call it hitting ,, its just to make him understand and realize that wrongs he made . Its tatally FORBIDDEN that you hit in the face ,,in any case its forbidden ,,, or in any place that might cause any harm to the child . hitting would be like pushing the kid with the hand more than hitting ,,, its a kind of touching ,, when the kid do something good ,, you touch him in a good way to make him feel good ,, when he does something wrong you touch him in a way to make him feel the bad thing he made . of course in certain age ,, for example you dont hit a 5 or 6 years old kid ,,,, he will become lunatic .
i will tell a story , once the prophet Muhammad pbuh - was praying ofcourse he lead people in the praying , then when he was bowing on the ground in which we call " Sujud " he took so much time so the people praying behind him thought he was dead . (( ofcourse they couldnt lift their heads up till the leader of the pray do that first )) then when he finished the pray they asked him why he took so much time ,, he said that his grand son ( i dont recall who was the grandson , Hasan or Husain , coz he had two ) his grandsone was on his back and he didnt want to make him fall if he lift up from the Sujud .
well,, its not an example of hitting ,,, but what i ment is that Islam gave too much attention to kids . not to harm them at any case , not only that the kid has his rights from the very first day , that he is born ,, the first thing is giving him a good name ,, its his right . now hitting him for behaving bad ,, is one of his rights ,, coz if we dont try to make him descipline ,,maybe he will become a very bad indiviual in the future ,, and this is happening .
now for forbidding hitting in Europe or america or whereever ,,,, why do you think they have forbiden it ???? i think coz of tooo much violence agaist kids and children !!! but on the other hand ,, preventing hitting is making the kid so out of control ,, ( and i dont mean controling his mind ) , and this is what is happening there ,,, if the parents try to make their child discipline and hit him ,, he will call the police and make them a big problem ,,, now will the police be able to make him disicipline ????? later ???
believe me ppl ,,its a relative thing according to the case itself .